GLEN CANYON & HITE OVERLOOK—The View for the Past 51 Years w/Jim Stiles (ZX#30)

For centuries, for thousands of years, humans struggled to find a way to cross what would someday be called The Colorado River. Sometimes a shallow part of the river provided such a crossing. Called “fords,’ critters of all types, including the ones who walked upright, could make their way across the river, when the water flow was low. One such ford would come to be known as Hite Crossing, named after the man who discovered the ford, Cass Hite. For decades men dreamed of building a bridge ir a ferry across the river. Such a project would connect the western and eastern sides of the state. Even after World War II, southeast Utah was one of the most remote and difficult to navigate parts of the Lower 48. But all that finally changed. In his excellent account of “The Event.” Zephyr contributor Barry Scholl described it like this:

In the annals of southern Utah history, September 17, 1946 was a day to be remembered. With proper pomp and circumstance—even the San Juan County High School Band—the Hite Ferry was dedicated. With the completion of the ferry it was now possible to travel by automobile all the way from Hanksville, across the Colorado River to White Canyon and onward to Blanding. The opening of Arth Chaffin’s homemade ferry represented the first vehicle crossing between Greenriver, Utah (for years, the name was generally written as a single word) and Lee’s Ferry, Arizona.

“Pioneer riverman Harry Aleson was the first speaker of the day. Before a crowd of 400, including Bishop E.P Pectol of Torrey, southeastern Utah pioneer Zeke Johnson, Utah State Roads Commissioner K.C. Wright, and Utah Governor Herbert Maw, Aleson described the effort that had gone into making the ceremony possible.

Hite Ferry. Photo by Ruben Nielsen

“For years Arthur Chaffin’s ranch was unquestionably the most isolated in the United States. He lived 120 miles from the nearest railroad and his nearest neighbor downstream on the Colorado was at Lee’s Ferry, 162 miles distant. The next neighbor on the river was the Bright Angel Trail, 251 miles away in the bottom of the Grand Canyon. His third nearest neighbor was my father’s son, who lived at MY HOME, Arizona, 442 miles away in the bottom of the mile-deep Grand Canyon.

“Arthur Chaffin’s ranch is still isolated—it is 70 miles from the nearest community—but today automobiles can reach the region, cross the river on the ferry, and continue on through Utah’s most colorful and primeval region, thanks to Governor Herbert B. Maw and the Utah State Department of Publicity.”


“Hard as it is to believe today, only 50 years ago one-tenth of Utah was cut off from automobile traffic, a region of scenic wonders known to only a few prospectors, adventurers and cattlemen. After years of what historian/journalist Barbara Ekker described as “construction work, sleepless nights, borrowed equipment, begged funds and sheer hard work,” Chaffin managed to almost single-handedly improve the road from Hanksville down North Wash to Glen Canyon, thereby opening the area to vehicles and tourists.”

But the “real world” was bound to catch up with Southeast Utah eventually. For the next 25 years, the gravel and dirt road from Blanding to Hanksville, with the ferry connecting the east and west sides of the Colorado, changed very little. In the 1950s, with the uranium boom in fill swing, major discoveries in and near White Canyon necessitated a better way to cross over the 2000 foot escarpment of Comb Ridge. A narrow one lane road was built by the Utah Department of Transportation and called it the “Comb Ridge dugway.” It was a scary ride, especially for the ore trucks, but most of them survived. Proof that some didn’t lies in the rusted remains of old trucks that can still be seen at the bottom of the canyon.

But in the late 1960s, plans were made to pave the entire Hanksville to Blanding Road. In addition they would have to find an alternative for the ferry. The waters of Lake Powell reached Hite by 1964. The ferry was gone. To replace this simple operation would not be easy. At pool level the lake would be too wide for a single bridge. And so UDOT devised a plan to connect the two sides of the river by constructing three new bridges. It was their only option. Coming from the east, the first formidable barrier was White Canyon. It was a narrow crossing but very, very deep. Once that obstacle was overcome, the new road descended toward the Colorado. At the point where Narrow Canyon meets the Glen, the largest of the three bridges crossed the Colorado River. Finally there was the Dirty Devil River to get over. Thus bridge number three.

When I first discovered the old Utah Hwy 95 in 1971, I was coming from the east and Blanding. The road stayed paved for just a few miles before it turned to dirt. I reached the top of the Comb Ridge Dugway, descended 2000 feet to the wash and then climbed out of the wooded verdant valley and onto Cedar Mesa. For a complete account of this story, read my account, “Live from Hadley Plain and Comb Wash.”

It was like another world, I saw no one. I camped near Natural Bridges and the next morning, crossed the three bridges and and ground my way up the steep incline on the west side to North Wash. But I saw a sign and hung a left to get an overview of the lake and the country I had just traversed. It was my first view from Hite Overlook. It was August 1, 1971. That drive changed my life. I had taken photos all along the 100 mile drive from Blanding, including the Overlook. But when I got back to Kentucky, on my first night home, someone broke into my VW Squareback on the U of L campus, and stole everything I owned. My clothes, my guitar, my camping gear…and five rolls of undeveloped Kodachrome film.I still grieve over those lost images.

Five months later, in early January I finally took my first image of the lake that I was able to hold on to. It was cold and clear and the road was dry. It was all just as I had remembered it.

Hite Overlook… January1972
Apologies for the blur. This was taken in October of 1975. My buddy Ranger Dave Evans and I had just made a harrowing ride over a very slushy, muddy, snow packed unpaved (at the time) Boulder Mountain Road. Like all such experiences, we were terrified at the time, but the memory of that late afternoon will always be with me. You can also notice that the lake has come up considerably in three years.
`In 1976, it appears the reservoir might have gone down some. I cant find a record of what month this photo was taken but it looks like winter and that would be the time of year when the reservoir would be at its lowest.
1977….This was a drought year. The water was so low at Moab that they had to cancel the annual Friendship Cruiser. I don’t think that event ever recovered fully from that year.
Looking a bit further downstream. Same shooting location. 1977
June 1978. My friend Cronk, the same guy who abandoned me in Florida (see hitchhiking story part 1), felt obligated to express his displeasure with the flooded Glen Canyon.
June 1978. Same film location without the urinating Cronk.
Maximum pool level (and beyond) July 1983. A late Spring runoff caused the reservoir to exceed its maximum pool level of 3700 feet (above sea level). Hastily constructed plywood flashing placed across the spillways by BuRec allowed the lake to rise by another eight feet. Had that measure not worked, it’s likely the dam would have failed. The power of the water flowing down the spillway tubes was chewing up the concrete lining of the diversion tunnel and spitting it into the river below. Had the water breached the sandstone walls on the upstream side of the dam, it would have been like pullling the plug on a bathtub. The damage such a breach would have caused down stream, and the loss of wildlife and human life would have been immeasurable.
1983, directly across from the Hite Overlook.
Looking downstream. The high water year. 1983
By the late 1980s, the lake level had started to decline. Note landforms that were under water just a few years earlier.
And by 1990. drought conditions had returned to the Southwest and the reservoir began to fall precipitously. I even ran a special page in a 1990 issue of The Zephyr, with photos of the Dirty Devil River. It was the first time that reservoir waters did not back up to the Dirty Devil bridge. Tamarisk had already re-established itself along the banks of the river,.
But the unpredictability of the seasonal snowpack finally convinced me to assume nothing. In the next few years, the lake rose again. This is from 1994. The lake was up again.
Summer 1994

From 2004. One of the first years to see the dramatic changes happening at Hite. Part of it was due to reduced stream flow, but the constant accumulation of silt carried downstream by the river began to have an impact. As the river reached the reservoir, its rate of flow slowed, and the silt fell out of solution. As far back as the 1960s, hydrologists predicted that this phenomenon would probably occur by the turn of the century. And it did.
The view from the Hite Bridge over the river. 2004
This was as low as the lake had been since it began to fill in 1963. That Spring a few of us traveled downstream from Halls Crossing to see the Cathedral in the Desert— out of the water for the first time in 40 years…Summer 2005
The Cathedral in the Desert. April 2005. First time (and only briefly) out of the reservoir since 1963. In the next few years, part of the Cathedral went under water again. Fifteen years later, it has re-emerged.
The lake appears up in this photo…the water almost reaches the concrete ramp at Hite.
August 2006
And by July 2011, the lake was back up again. But the image fails to show just how much silt lies under the water. A drop of just a few feet would expose the silty plain. And in two years, that’s exactly what happened…
Looking upstream to the bridge in 2013
…and downstream in the summer 2013
Looking downstream from the Overlook. You can see the boat ramp at the Hite Marina, high and dry in this image from summer 2014
Another wet winter and the reservoir rose again, almost covering the silt. Summer 2017
But a year later...July 2018
July 2019
Sunset. July 2020
August 2021. My last photograph. Since then the reservoir has fallen another 30 feet,
AND NOW…back to the beginning. The confluence of the Dirty Devil and Colorado Rivers, just upstream from the Hite Ferry. photo credit: WL Rusho. 1959
…and from close to the same location by air, courtesy pilot Paul Swanstrom. 2005

AND FINALLY

Coming soon…there’s another story about the Hite ferry and the people that lived there that has rarely been told. In this photo, the rising waters have finally reached Hite and this odd contraption was built in an attempt to salvage materials about to be flooded. But do you know who Ruben and Beth Nielsen were? And do you know what an integral part they played in the life of Hite? Coming in the next few weeks, photos and stories you’ve never heard or seen…JS

TO LEAVE A COMMENT, DCROLL TO THE BOTTOM OF THIS PAGE. WE APPRECIATE YOUR OBSRVATIONSS

The Zephyr Blue Moon Extra posts on Monday Mornings
,
https://www.facebook.com/FansoftheCanyonCountryZephyr
If you want to get on our email list, just write “sign me up” in the subject line and email it to: cczephyr@gmail.com

14 comments for “GLEN CANYON & HITE OVERLOOK—The View for the Past 51 Years w/Jim Stiles (ZX#30)

  1. October 10, 2022 at 12:31 am

    What a consistently rewarding overlook, after cannonballing down North Canyon. I can never stop myself from pulling off at the Hite Overlook, and no matter how much of a hurry I’m in I can get away in no less than 90 minutes or so, often two hours. The view changes a lot over seasons and years. For more striking photos of the changes in the prospects, see Annette McGivney’s and James Kay’s book Resurrection, which includes big prints of the Hite CrossIng through the later ’90s and into the 2000s. Even without shade on a hot day, the view is irresistable.

  2. Donna Andress
    October 10, 2022 at 9:29 am

    Excellent story and the pictures tell it all! Am forwarding this to friends who live in Page. this history is not well known and thank you for telling it! Most sincerely, Donna Like the cartoon of CJ and Gail

  3. Catherine Lutz
    October 10, 2022 at 10:22 am

    This is an incredible documentation of history and a fascinating way to present the critical issue of water in the west, aridification and climate change, and the consequences of man’s actions to control natural forces. I am eager to see the coming stories. Bravo!

  4. Kay
    October 10, 2022 at 10:47 am

    What an interesting article and the photos are so good at telling the story of what has happened to the river and Lake Powell as seen from the overlook.

  5. bob london
    October 10, 2022 at 11:01 am

    Great pictures, Stiles. Seeing the reservoir at, or near, full pool in the ‘Hite’ marina area is, simultaneously, fascinating and ghastly.

    I believe the ferry between the real Hite, with Chaffin’s farm, and the settlement of White Canyon operated at an elevation of ~3443 feet above mean sea level and was inundated in June 1964 when the water was rising rather quickly.

    However, by August 1964 – with the reservoir elevation at ~3485 – a temporary ferry was operating out of North Wash to a point on the opposite (east) bank close to where the future marina would have its southern (primative) ramp.

    This ferry was operating on the flat waters of Powell and, therefore, needed no guide cables. Just a propeller and a skipper that knew the lie of the land.

    For over a year, and with the water constantly rising, the operater of the ferry chased old 95 back up North Wash, at least until late-September 1965, to provide some access from the road that people were familiar with.

    I have photos of this stop-gap ferry from both North Wash and the east side of the proto-reservoir but obviously can’t post them here.

    Anyway, by ’66 the shiny new bridge was operational, the reservoir was half-full and everyone was happy.

    • bob london
      October 11, 2022 at 12:07 pm

      P.S. Somewhat ironically, the later photos I’ve seen of the temporary ferry in North Wash, dated 21st September 1965, were taken when the reservoir was at an identical elevation to that of today: 3530 feet above mean sea level.

      Now the flat water at 3530 is over ten miles downstream from where those 1965 photographs were taken.

      As an aside, Jim: If you and your dodgy mates have been urinating off Hite overlook since 1971, can any of you remember when Hite marina came into being? When was the concrete for the ramp poured?

      I know the first, basic, ‘Hite’ marina was set up in Glen Cove on the opposite side of the reservoir where, these days, the river runners haul their rigs out. The early marina was definitely in use from early ’66 until at least ’69.

      At some point Glen Cove became impractical for the boat people and Hite marina on the east shore was brought into service. This must have been a smooth overlap considering how many dollars were riding on access to the far-north of the reservoir, surely?

      So, do you, Stiles, or any of your other seven readers (that’s a little joke) know when the modern, now defunct, Hite marina on the eastern shore of Powell reservoir came ‘online’?

  6. Kathi Lind Mottram
    October 10, 2022 at 1:22 pm

    Thank you for these photos! Amazing to see them and compare them year to year. Worked at Hite in 1977 and the takeout for the river trips was right up at the boat ramp. With a little dock to tie up to as well. Are there and photos of the Marina as it was? Hard to find.
    It’s very satisfying to see see the last couple of photos look so similar.

  7. David von Borstell
    October 10, 2022 at 3:16 pm

    Thank you for this photo record and info. While I love the southwest rivers and high plateau everything about this impoundment has been very dispiriting to me. It would be renewing to see more of the old canyon become available again.

  8. Kathleen
    October 10, 2022 at 6:43 pm

    Wonderful history and photos. I have been to Lake Powell twice, 2004 and 2015. These photos and history are so valuable. Thanks for informing everyone who loves this place about the past and present. Ed Abbey would be so proud of you for doing this.

  9. Evan Cantor
    October 10, 2022 at 7:17 pm

    Incredible documentation, illustrates the issue better than anything I’ve seen.

  10. Steven Moore, (the other)
    October 10, 2022 at 10:34 pm

    A great visual story! I’ve been personally watching this unfold myself since 1970, when I worked my first season at Natural Bridges National Monument. And now I’m back working successive seasons there 52 years later. So I traveled those shiny bridges when they were only 4 years old.

    I enjoyed your account in 1971 seeing the Comb Ridge Dugway for the first time. I wonder if we met that summer. My bride was freaked the first time we went over it, but she got used to it quickly enough. Considering that the Moki Dugway, almost as thrilling, was the other major access route, we rangers at the Bridges would greet the incoming visitors, some still shaking, and when they would ask “Is there a better road out of here”, we’d ask them “Which road did you come in on?” Not what they wanted to hear.

    As for the Lake, which I do not miss, I took my first backpack trip into lower Dark Canyon in 1981, where our group was picked up by a concession boat for transportation to Hite. That was repeated in 1983 and 1985, as I assumed leadership of those trips. My next one was 1989; this time we exited by the Sundance Trail, but not before hiking to the mouth of Dark Canyon. The river was flowing serenely past. No boat pickup this time. Incidentally, I missed seeing Colin Fletcher, author of “River” by 2 or 3 days as he journeyed out of Cataract Canyon that year.

    And the Lake has never penetrated Dark Canyon since! And, honestly, despite the silt, I enjoy looking downriver from Hite as far as I can see, and dreaming of the unearthing history that is reappearing beyond my sight. Looking forward to your next “Hite” article.

  11. October 11, 2022 at 1:48 pm

    I played a lot of music with Will Barclay. His grandfather was Arth Chaffin and Will lives in Arth’s old Teasdale house. Will had lots of stories about Arthur and he gave me a box of Arth’s old paperwork. Included was a letter Arth sent to the feds, trying to get some graves moved as lake foul came to be. My song Pirates Of The Colorado came directly from stuff Arth had written…

  12. October 11, 2022 at 2:47 pm

    Great work Jim! Thank you for doing this. Cordially yours, Tom

  13. Stephen Verchinski
    October 11, 2022 at 8:00 pm

    Before many blame this climate change fully on anthroprogenic creation and that we must all give up our rights and soverignty to global banksters and UN globalists I urge caution. I sat as a panelist and guest speaker in 1990 with the Aspen Institute and CFR member, Dr. William W. Kellogg who co wrote one of the seminal books on climate and society. A fellow CFR member, Tim Wirth, told a reporter that year, “We have to ride the global warming issue. Even if the theory of global warming is wrong, we will be doing the right thing in terms of economic policy and environmental policy.”

    I bring it up as a person having a broad natural resources science background as well as one who studied as a minor, geography. Humans role in changing the face of the earth has been a constant in 6,000 years as well as their adaptations. Global warming theory and models have been proferred to the global community in an effort imo to cause panic and undermine national soverignty and our Bill of Rights to groups like the WEF (who I call the World Enslavement Forum) It doesn’t have to go that way.

    A 50% reduction in human carbon-energy use can be achieved without them with a good monthly fee and dividend system in place. With a bit of education I trust many to make good decisions. The elites of Davos don’t like that approach because it moves much of the control back to the public.

    The current projections of global energy use FYI, with the “Great Reset”, is showing no real reductions past 2050. If this is catastrophic I can say that it happened before to many cultures across this planet. Just look at the Anazasi, the Sahara and more. Read works by George Perkins Marsh. It has happened before.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *