There's a lot of talk in the West these days about the stockman's
long-time nemesis. Whether you refer to them as cougar, mountain
lion, puma, catamount, or panther, they're all the same species:
Felis concolor. The big cat is making headlines not for preying upon
cattle, but people.
Last January, two mountain bikers in Southern California were mauled,
one fatally. They are the latest unfortunate victims as human encroachment
into mountain lion habitat takes its tragic and perhaps inevitable
toll. Other attacks on humans have occurred in recent years in Montana,
Colorado, and other parts of California.
Missing from the media blitz, however, is any mention of another
feline predator in the West that is crossing paths more frequently
with Homo sapiens: the jaguar. Contrary to popular belief, the mountain
lion's larger cousin is not exclusively a jungle animal. In fact,
the adaptable and stealthy jaguar has long had a home north of the
border, extending within the last century onto the Colorado Plateau.
Since 1900, scores of jaguars have been seen in Arizona and New Mexico,
most often by sport-hunters and stockmen who promptly killed them.
Documented sightings have been made as far north as the Grand Canyon
and near Winslow in Arizona, and within the Gila Wilderness of south-central
New Mexico. During the 1800s, jaguars roamed southern California
and possibly parts of Colorado and Louisiana. Stephen Houston found
jaguars "in abundance" throughout the Rio Grande Valley
of Texas during the 1840s. There have been no documented sightings
reported in Utah, though fossil evidence places them as far north
as Idaho and Washington during prehistoric times.
Fortunately, jaguar attacks on humans are rare, with none reported
in the modern era north of Central America. But like all large carnivores,
some jaguars will occasionally prey on livestock if the opportunity
arises, which explains the cat's virtually extirpation from the Southwest
by the 1950s. With a government-decreed bounty on its head, the jaguar
was shot on sight. Back in 1972, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
acknowledged the jaguar's endangered status worldwide but inexplicably
forgot to place the animal on the list of U.S. endangered species.
The situation began to change in 1996, however, when Arizona rancher
Warner Glenn and his trained lion-tracking hounds cornered a big
male jaguar in the Peloncillo range of New Mexico's bootheel. Since
then at least four confirmed sightings, all 30 or fewer miles north
of Arizona's border with Mexico, have been made of jaguars or their
tracks.
The excitement of wildlife enthusiasts at the return of this charismatic
beast is tempered, however, by an intense squabble over how state
and federal authorities should handle the jaguar. Conservationists,
some of whom have sued the Fish and Wildlife Service over this issue,
want to lay out the welcome mat for jaguars by designating critical
habitat and implementing a recovery plan. They point out that the
cat may be fleeing Sonora, where a remnant population about 130 miles
south of the border is being hunted (illegally) by backcountry ranchers.
At least seven jaguars have been killed in Sonora since 1999 and
less than 100 may be left. Once their gone, experts agree, wild jaguars
will disappear permanently from the American West.
It appears that all jaguars encountered in the U.S. since 1996 have
been males, probably transients seeking new territory. Some activists
are hopeful that a breeding population may eventually establish itself
in the rugged "sky island" ranges south of Tucson and west
of El Paso. The sticking point has been the reluctance of area ranchers
and other interested parties to promote habitat protection for an
animal that many still believe poses a threat to their livestock.
Jaguars have similar depredation habits as mountain lions, which
continue to be shot by local ranchers. While some cattle-growers
are intrigued by the presence of a few jaguars and will tolerate
them as an exotic species, others cling to the old notion that any
wild cat is a varmint. A few ranchers support a middle way, through
participation with environmentalists, scientists, and bureaucrats
in the quasi-official Jaguar Conservation Team, which meets regularly
in New Mexico and Arizona to develop protection strategies.
According to New Mexico-based Michael Robinson of the Center for
Biological Diversity, one of the groups that sued Fish and Wildlife
over jaguar management, it's unlikely that jaguars will flourish
in the Southwest without extra help. Reintroduction is unlikely,
given the scarcity of jaguars in northern Mexico and the difficulty
in capturing them. Transplanted jungle cats would probably be unable
to adapt to an arid climate and a prey base dominated by deer, javelina,
and coati. Therefore, the animal's last best hope may be designation
of critical habit as a kind of de facto sanctuary.
After millennia in the Southwest, time may be running out for the
jaguar. Besides the dwindling breeding population in Sonora, things
are getting tougher for all wildlife along la frontera. The U.S.
Border Patrol is cracking down on an ever-greater number of undocumented
Latin Americans crossing illegally from Mexico. The agency estimates
that the Arizona-Sonora frontier is penetrated each year by hundreds
of thousands of "illegals" as well as drug smugglers, many
of whom unwittingly hike through prime jaguar habitat on their way
to a presumed better life in El Norte.
The images of undocumented entrants often show up on the 30 motion-triggered
camera traps set up to monitor jaguars near the border.
This disturbance is compounded by the invasive strategies the Border
Patrol uses to secure the U.S.-Mexico boundary: frequent land and
air inspections, bright lights, high walls, and barbed-wire fencing.
In recent years, self-appointed vigilantes have joined the enforcement
effort, trying to stem the tide of unsanctioned (and, to their minds,
unwanted) immigration.
Now comes word of the latest potential deterrent to jaguar survival
in the area. Last July, the Tucson Electric Power Company announced
the proposed construction of a major high-voltage power line from
Tucson south into Mexico. As outlined, the project would extend directly
through an area near Nogales where a (possibly resident) jaguar has
been observed three times by professional trackers since 2001.
"Within the last year, the border has become a very difficult
place to work," conceded Jack Childs, the Arizona land surveyor
who videotaped a jaguar in the Boboquíívari Mountains
eight years ago. Childs, who monitors some of the remote cameras
set up to photograph these wayward cats, told members of the Jaguar
Conservation Team in August that he now packs a gun while on patrol. "If
we're going to save the jaguar, we've got to act fast, and we're
going to need help."
Richard Mahler is a free-lance writer who is writing a book about
jaguars.