TWO ARTS
Yesterday I happened to be looking through the open back doorway
of the cabin. A housefly's flight came to an abrupt stop and there
came the barn spider on its invisible line. Reaching the fly, the
spider wrapped it with a few strokes and then subsided, legs tucked
in, motionless. I imagined it quietly taking in body fluids of the
fly. Next day I went tots webwork and touched the upper right anchor.
Immediately the spider shifted, aimed itself at my finger. I jerked
back, the spider turned in one smooth movement to resume its original
position, alert status ended, tucked again into a spider's pond of
calm, not that I know what that is.
Usually a calm for us modern humans seems to be a sort of affair:
partial, frets and concerns not quite gone. One of those took me
today as I looked through that same doorway, back to another place,
other times, the Red Desert of Wyoming. I was with a bird watcher
friend and Grant Hagen, Jackson Hole native and wonderful animal
artist. We wandered up Steamboat mountain, in no hurry, pooling our
fragmentary knowledge of plants and rocks, animals and history; patrolling
cliff tops, accompanied by a pair of screaming prairie falcons, finding
what we decided might very well be the buffalo drop that Dave Love,
Wyoming geologist, had mentioned.
We looked out from time to time at one of North America's grand
far-ranging landscapes. The scene shifted to more recent times, Steamboat
again, with three veteran Red Desert defenders: Tom Bell, wildlife
biologist and founder of High Country News, Mac Blewer, outreach
director of Wyoming Outdoor Council, and Marian Doane, a most knowledgeable
woman who can read the range. Neither of those days were like quiet
dreams nor were they times of fret; they were hour after hour of
real living. You know what I mean, I won't dissect it.
The Red Desert intrudes here because it does, that's all. I've mentioned
it before, that great country that merges with other high plains
regions spreading north past the Big Horns into Montana, south into
Colorado, east toward the Medicine Bows. But it's time, friends,
skeptics, activists of every stripe, ranchers, workers in the oil
and gas patches, BLM people ... yes, you too ... it's time, the bell
tolls. We've got to stop and turn and find the crossroads where we
went wrong. Because that land is under the hammer, on the brink.
We all have our special places ... home towns, streets, city blocks,
mountains, valleys, desert oases ... places that can't be violated
without a very damn good reason, such as life, liberty and the pursuit
of happiness. Places where the bottom line of Exxon or Mobil or BP
or WalMart has no standing. For me the Red Desert is not only one
of those, it has become a vibrant set of instructions written on
the land, directions to what is happening elsewhere.
So hear me out. The crossroad where we went wrong was our backing
away from linking to other groups to fight for a rigorous and radical
overhaul of federal and state energy policy. Instead, the prime focus,
money and bombast were expended on defense of the Arctic National
Wildlife Refuge, a part of the circumpolar arctic, all of which is
now, and will be (refuge included) in the gunsights of fossil fuel
corporations worldwide.
Other lands in the Americas, Asia, Africa are targeted too. It was
too easy to think in that small-scale, piecemeal activist cage known
as the art of the politically possible. We could have thrown down
a gauntlet, insisted on a a wide-ranging ecological/political ground
on which to struggle. We could have been talking a lot more to each
other, making contacts, building confidence, breaking barriers, building
a truly independent grassroots base. Is it too late, to advance the
art of democracy.?
Hard row to hoe? Sure, but maybe not quite so tough, once we get
into the swing of it, and once we take seriously the fact that the
earth does not wait on us, is not under our command, has its own
time scale. What that means right now is a huge gap between what
has to be done and what we take to be possible. Take the Kerry campaign.
No, let's not. Let's look at one of those gaps, neatly summarized
by Ross Gelbspan.
"The scientists (who had previously reported to a 1995 United
Nations panel) subsequently concluded that to stabilize our climate
requires humanity to cut its use of coal and oil by 70 percent in
a very short time. In contrast, the Kyoto Protocol calls for industrial
countries to cut aggregate emissions by just 5.2 percent by 2014." The
Nation, Aug. 15-23, 2004).
Our nation won't even abide by the pitiful, embarrassing, totally
ridiculous Kyoto goal. You see what I'm driving at? A bold, overarching
strategy for rescue of the Red Desert and other places at risk would
link directly to a bold and realistic strategy for moderating global
warming.
Being bold these days runs counter to what most of us think of as
realistic. Granted. But things have been going very, very wrong lately;
we see it and feel it and know that somehow something's got to give,
even if it means pulling back from that American dream world we look
at every day on the screen: squeaky clean bathrooms, perfect grooming,
mowed-to-the-roots chem lawn, shampooed dog, well fed cat, plastic
objects everywhere, products galore.
What could be
more realistic than a look behind those fake scenes— Poison
brew from PVC plastic manufacture; leaks and spills on the Alaska
pipeline; radioactive storage in Navaho country; cascading consequences
of damming the Colorado river; criminal waste of two of earth's most
precious materials: oil and water. And who's counting war damage?
It's a time to be bold; might be too late; wouldn't that be sad?
Who could we blame?
I was in the midwest during the Reagan apotheosis. Myriads of flags,
yellow ribbons on vehicles, power poles, houses. But behind all that,
another presence, the dry earth.. Newspapers, printing without fail
the national boilerplate, also spent many column inches, and photos
too, on the drought. Government offices were prime sources of news;
Water Districts, Bureau of Reclamation, Geological Survey, Bureau
of Land Management, Agricultural Extension ... wherever some hope
or help might be found.
Droughts come
and go. We can't engineer them out of existence. What we can do
is adapt, by drastic measures, which we are not taking,
because we've been trained to think only within the bounds of "Get
the government off our backs." But government is absolutely
essential and the arid land crisis is proving that. The real issue
is not what, but who. The art of the politically possible, a pathogen,
most virulent in the Beltway and media-land, but its spores spread
across the land, infecting the rest of us who live with real consequences.
We're hamstrung by fear of stepping over the line; we're afraid of
being labeled radical, naive, utopian, revolutionary, or worse.
CHEATGRASS
The latest issue of the Zephyr opened up an important piece of the
ecological/political puzzle: alien plants (aka noxious weeds). I'll
add my bit.
A July day in
Horse Canyon, northern Nevada. Cheatgrass was abundant, especially
along the cattle trail. Barbed "florets" snagged
my sneakers and socks and worked into the fabrics and stabbed. Dozens
of them, and they were hard to dislodge. Lacking forceps I went after
the worst ones with my teeth. Humiliating, time-consuming. I tried
walking barefoot, but the trail was too rocky. There were no alternate
routes, the narrow canyon bottoms being literally choked by a noisy
stream and its tall jungle. Finally, I simply held a steady pace,
accepting pain.
Cheatgrass, Bromus tectorum, invaded from Europe in the 1880s and
found ideal conditions on roadsides and other exposed places. It
competes with native plants, but does not necessarily displace them.
It can be beautiful in early summer, pale green and silky in shimmering
masses. Grazing animals can use it then, before it dries and polishes
its armament.
The canyon broadened and branched, cheatgrass dwindled, having met
the fringes of a new set of conditions: alpine-like meadows. I stopped
at the creek bank and worked on shoes and socks. The sun was low.
Decision time. Should I run the gauntlet again? I drank from the
canteen. Not much left. Afraid of Giardia, I didn't take water from
the creek.
I decided to try for the spine of the range and follow that down
and out. It was hard traveling, heaving upward through aromatic brush.
The ridges ahead began to reveal their complexities. Too much unknown
territory up there, and I'd be moving in thirst and darkness. Not
wise.
I retreated,
took the cheatgrass way, settled into a steady grind. Pain, some
bloodshed. I made it to the car and poked it along a two-track
road. Erosion ruts, sounds of sifting dust and ghostly dry brush
scraping by, and then the highway embankment loaded with shimmers
of pinkish-brown Bromus tectorum, ripe and ready. Not long after
that encounter I holed up in a Bureau of Land Management campground
in Wyoming. I brewed coffee and read a glossy little BLM pamphlet
called Noxious Weeds. A Growing Concern. Ten of the aliens were identified.
Spotted Knapweed, Leafy Spurge, and so on. They are bad because they "displace
native plant species that provide habitat for wildlife and food for
people and livestock." One of them is poisonous. The pamphlet
tells us that we can all help with invasions by not transporting
unknown flowers, by not giving our horses feed that might contain
noxious seeds, and by driving only on "established roads and
trails." Cheatgrass wasn't mentioned. Next day was a good one.
I followed elk and deer and wild horse trails and logging roads to
a fine view of Whiskey Peak. Back in camp I re-read Noxious Weeds.
Some of the swatches of yellow color in meadows and old clearcuts
had looked suspiciously like one of the aliens, Dalmatian Toadflax.
If so, I wanted to know if it is really serious, or moderately so,
and what are the realistic chances of defeating it. Will it exterminate
Paintbrush, Geranium, Phlox, Wild Buckwheat and the other good, solid
Americans? Or might they all arrive at some sort of coexistence and
in the process add a bit more color and variety to the ecosystem.
But wouldn't the answers to these questions vary, depending on each
terrain's degree of erosion and grazing, its fire regime, floral
composition, soil structure, weather pattern? The pamphlet had only
a color photo of Dalmatian Toadflax and five words of description, "...extensive
and deep root system." It's noxious, never mind the details,
take our word for it. That was the message.
A tad irritated, I turned contrary, began a list of other invaders
of these mountains, beginning with myself and my gear and vehicle
and my fellow campers who were lounging at creekside or under RV
awnings, wetting fish lines, fussing with fires and grills, giving
their four-wheelers a workout.I recalled the wealth of information
that turned up in my previous cheatgrass research. Fascinating stuff.
Soil and climate and altitude preferences; growth habit; season of
danger to grazers; fire hazard; experiments in progress to determine
where it might be a threat, and where possibly not.
Come on, BLM,
trust us, give us more data and the big picture. We might take
an interest. With what you're giving us so far you can't
really believe we'll go all bushy-tailed to make ourselves activists
in the war against aliens. We've got enough troubles. Oh, we might
refrain from picking and transporting beautiful strangers, but I
don't see many of us making sure that "within 96 hours before
entering back country (we) give pack animals only food that is certified
weed free."
Come to think of it, I wonder if the battles against noxious aliens
are already being lost because of reckless building of logging and
mining and oil/gas roads into back country, under your supervision.
You can't blame us for wondering why you and the Forest Service don't
get together and wipe out a few thousand miles of old roads and two-tracks
whose total mileage now exceeds that of the entire interstate system.
Never mind, I'm out of here. What's this? A little brown envelope
into which I forgot to enclose the camping fee. Damn, this is really
irritating. If you feds need more money, and I'm sure you do, and
I'm all for it, go get it from taxes and you know which brackets
to hit. This is our land, you know; this is public land. Okay? Oh
well, thanks for not charging me a trailhead fee. (Cheatgrass is
a shortened version of a piece first published in the Anderson Valley
Advertiser, Aug. 11, 1999).